New York New York - Surrey, British Columbia
Tue - Thu: 04:30 PM - 08:30 PM
Fri - Sat: 04:30 PM - 09:00 PM
Sun: 04:30 PM - 08:30 PM
New York New York, nestled in the heart of Surrey, offers a vibrant taste of the Big Apple in Canada. This lively establishment is renowned for its eclectic menu, blending classic New York favorites with a modern twist. Guests can indulge in everything from savory deli sandwiches to gourmet pizzas, all within a welcoming, urban atmosphere. Perfect for casual dining and special gatherings alike, it’s a local gem that promises a memorable culinary journey.
Check out TOP-10 Best Greek restaurants in Surrey, British ColumbiaMenu
Starters
Kalamari
Spanakopita
Tzatziki and Pita
Tater Kegs
Hummus and Pita
Chicken Fingers with Fries
Falafel Bites
Soutzoukakia
Chicken Wings
Saganaki
Chicken Fingers
Kolokithakia
Keftethakia
Appetizer Platter
Black Tiger Prawns
Dolmathes
Athenian Prawns
Salads
Greek Salad
Caesar Salad
Athenian Salad
Caesar Salad with Shrimp
Caesar Salad with Chicken
Dinner Entrées
Chicken Souvlaki
Roast Lamb a L'astoria
Liberty Lamb Chops
Platter for Two
Spanakopita Platter
Kalamari Platter
Beef Souvlaki
Moussaka Platter
Greek Style Ribs
Lamb Souvlaki
Chicken Parmigiano
Bbq Baby Back Ribs
New York Steak Dinner 12 oz.
Veggie Platter for Two
Veal Schnitzel Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmegiano
NY Monster Platter!!!
New York Steak Dinner 10 oz.
Seafood Entrées
Prawn Souvlaki
Steak and Prawn Dinner (10 Oz)
Grilled Salmon
Pasta
New York House Fettuccini w/ Italian sausage
New York House Fettuccini w/ chicken
Tri-Color Rotini
Seafood Fettuccini
Pesto Pasta
Herb Chicken Penne
Kids Menu
Chicken Souvlaki
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Tri-color rotini (Plain)
Chicken Tri-color Rotini
Dessert
Ecmek
Tiramisu
New York New York Cheesecake
Baklava
Chocolate Almond Torte
Bougatsa
Tuxedo Truffle Mousse Cake
Red Velvet Cake
Extras
Chicken Skewer
Large Tzatziki
Tzatziki
Roast Potatoes (3 Halves)
Hommus
Pita
French Fries
Lamb Skewer
Side Rice
Large Rice
Prawn Skewer
Beef Skewer
Side Feta
Reviews for New York New York in Surrey, British Columbia
Kalamari has completely changed from their previous recipe along with their portions. Very disappointing.
Went here with my husband on Saturday night. We both ordered the same Kalamari Platter. The calamari was not as I had remembered it from 7 years ago when we visited last. What we were served was thick, overcooked, and chewy calamari. The tomato’s were overripe and mealy, and the ... rice was overcooked. The pita was also a bit tough like it was toasted then sat to dry out. Was really disappointing to spend $65 for two plates of food of that quality. :( Edit May 28/24 - The restaurant replied below but they must be talking about someone else. My husband and I haven’t travelled in years because we have small kids and we have never been to Greece. We also never ordered alcohol, and we didn’t finish our plates, or ask for discounts. So clearly they are thinking we are someone else. We were polite to our server, but figured there was no use saying something in the restaurant because we didn’t want to eat the same calamari even if remade. So, now after the incredibly aggressive response from the owner clearly mistaking us for other customers, we will continue to not recommend as clearly they’re also really rude. Read more
Went to this place with my family a couple of weeks ago and I must say that I was pleasantly surprised. We ordered the Monster platter and it was delicious. We could also make a few substitutions to it and I was really happy with that flexibility. I think that ... the prices are a bit on the higher side but the food is quiet delicious. If you like Greek Food, you should totally check this place out. Read more
Came here with my boyfriend as he highly recommended it and I was not disappointed! The servers who served us took very good care of us and gave us very good recommendations on what foods to eat! And the food was delectable~ Would highly recommend if you're craving for some ... calamari/greek food! Will come here again in the future, bringing my family with me. Read more
The service was lovely, the staff was all super friendly. The restaurant is quite noisy when full. There’s no mood music, just the babble of conversations. The moussaka was yummy, but the other items in the platter were underwhelming. The rice was barely warm and the Greek salad was quite bland. Serving sizes ... were noticeably smaller than my last visit about a year ago. Still a perfectly reasonable meal, just don’t expect to take home leftovers. The platters include only half a piece of pita bread and there was a small charge for hot water. Read more