Bagels On Fire - Toronto, Ontario

Ordered a BLT with extra bacon. A passable amount of bacon but it definitely was not "extra bacon". The bagel was not cut in half, was on a angle which made it sloppy. The bagle was wrapped in paper which stuck to the bagel on one spot and I had ... to rip it off to avoid eating it. The staff are wearing hair nets, but I found a hair in my bagle. The lettuce was also not super fresh, the tomato slices were fine. Overall was disappointed since it was about $13 for the BLT and a ice coffee. Probably won't come back. Read more

2024 April 4★ Small bagel shop with a fire oven. Bagels come out fresh and hot. Standard choices of flavors: everything, onion, sesame, poppyseed and even coconut.. Dozen mixed bagels $15.25 Bagels were definitely good. Just enough chewiness and fluffiness. Though a bit sweeter and more flavorful. Worth checking out if you are in ... the area. Limited seating options. Limited to about 4 persons. Washroom downstairs and not handicapped accessible. Read more

I love the bagel sandwiches here, but usually when I get a dozen to go many of them are underbaked and gummy. Yesterday I bought 6 everything bagels and 4/6 were inedible (see photo). Unfortunate because i love mtl style bagels and half of the time they are really good ... here, but the inconsistency makes me not want to come back :( Read more

It was my first time here and tied everything bagel sandwich and onion bagel sandwich. The bagels are really nice. It reminded of the bagels that I ate in Montreal. The bagels were made fresh and tasted perfect. Best bagel that I have had in Toronto. Though the Sandwichs could have ... been better or may be I wasn’t aware of ordering a right one. The place has just two tables for seating where only 4 people can sit. Read more

A good spot for a snack or breakfast bagel cravings! BF and I ordered our bagels on UberEats as we were in a hurry, but we wanted something quick just to fill our stomachs. We got the Salmon Lox and Cream Cheese Bagel sandwich, perfect smoked salmon and cream cheese ... combo sandwich, à perfect balance of crunch and softness of the pumpernickel bagel as it heightened and not over mask the other flavours of the sandwich. The second bagel we got was the Montreal smoked meat bagel sandwich on everything bagel, perfect classic creation, nothing too fancy if you are looking something to satisfy your cravings. Quality was amazing, customer service was nice and quick 👍🏻 Read more