Pie Guys Pizzeria - St. Catharines, Ontario

Not a big fan of party trays, but had to get it for office lunch. Both trays came to around $95. Everybody enjoyed the lunch, the pizzas were good. However, the cheese could've been a little bit more to hold the toppings together better.

I came in on their 50% off day (Monday) this week. The staff at the register were very calm and assuring despite how busy it was. My pizza and wing combo wasn't ready yet and when I pressed a little just to get an estimated time, one of the ladies ... in what I assume is kitchen area gave me a stink eye, then started whispering to the other people there while staring right at me. Not a good attitude to have at all, it's not the customers fault you're too slow to finish the order in a timely manner. When I got my pizza and wings, the food was alright, it tasted like any other in the Niagara region. I'm giving 2 stars because the kitchen staff seems to have a terrible attitude towards their customers, I can't imagine what it's like working back there. Read more

Pizza is always good, little greasy but that’s okay. Wings are different everytime. First time they were rock hard and barely sauced. Second time they were not crispy but perfectly sauced and this time (picture below) not very saucy but crispy. Will try again to see but will check prior ... to leaving. Read more

$$$ Ordered the Italian Stallion (medium) and 2lbs of hot honey wings Pizza, no complaints. Amount of toppings was appropriate, had plenty of flavour. Downsides; We recieved honey garlic wings NOT the wings we ordered. Delivery took an hour, that being said the delivery person was pleasant and friendly. 64$ approx = dinner for 2, all ... in all our dinner was great quality. Read more

Have gone here many times over the years and never had any issues! Their wings are great size and they do wing deals certain nights of the week (Tues and Thursday) We got a 24 slice and 3 pounds combo, all together was fair priced and all was cooked and ... tasted great. Discovered they had cup and char pepperoni too- love it! Read more