Pete’s Pizza - St. Catharines, Ontario

Ordered from the Pleasant Ave Pete's Pizza the other day and Im disappointed to say it was the worst pizza I've ever had. There was a cm thick slab of cheese on it and I don't believe there was any sauce on it at all. Oddly, the dough was either ... undercooked or something happened because it was so soggy the entire thing fell apart to an extent I had never seen before in a pizza. Went to this location a ton as a kid a few decades ago. I don't remember it being like this. Read more

First time ordering again since we were first married we ordered a 24 slice with extra cheese bacon and mushrooms and absolutely still and remains by far the best pizza we have had loaded with bacon bursting with flavor i highly reccomend you give them a try you ... wont regret it you havent had pizza till you have had petes Read more

I’m on vacation here from USA, and we wanted some good pizza, came accross this place browsing the internet and took a chance and drove 25 minutes from our hotel room just to try this place and let me tell you , pizza was Amazing!!!!! I would definitely come back ... on my next vacation!!!! Read more

This placed used to be my go to. I was recently reminded of it and how much I loved the bacon they use. I placed an order for a 12 slice pepperoni, a 12 slice canadian, 2lbs of wings and a garlic bread with cheese. $71 before tip When the order arrived ... the delivery person said she was supposed to notify me they included a extra 4 slice pizza because there was a issue with one of my pizzas I ordered. There was definitely a huge issue and the 12 slice canadian I ordered was disgusting. The bacon was huge chunks of pure fat, there seemed to be no sauce, the crust was paper thin and wet. Totally unedible. The garlic bread was a soggy mess yet nobody dared to even try it. The employees recognized the pizza was bad that's why they sent a free 4 slice but why? Why not send me what I paid for and remake the 12 slice. Why replace it with 4 slice and still send me the bad pizza? The 4 slice pizza was great, the pepperoni pizza was great and just as I expected and same goes for the wings. How I got an order where half was so gross and the other half perfect is beyond me. I reached out to the company by email and on social media. I emailed the email address listed by the company and received a reply stating they have nothing to do with the business and don't know why customers keep emailing them. I received a reply on Facebook that said "call Rino" with a phone number. I called a few times the next day and nobody ever answered. I've waited a week to see if anyone cared about the issue before leaving this review. The unprofessionalism and not making it right on a $70 order is what will have me never ordering from them again. Read more

I ordered the 3 topping, 4 Slice Pizza + 1 Pop for $6.99. I've read the reviews of the "fancy pizza" places close by. Stop wasting your money. These guys make an amazing pie. This little pizza was ready for pickup in 10 min. Fresh toppings were loaded on, with ... just the right amount of tomato sauce underneath. I haven't had pizza so perfect in awhile. I'll definitely reorder from this classic location. Read more