Restaurant Address Copied to Clipboard
Home / Ontario / St. Catharines

Pie Guy’s Pizzeria - St. Catharines, Ontario

Italian, Pizza
Pie Guy’s Pizzeria photo1
Ontario, St. Catharines
Open Now Closed
10 Mac Turnbull Drive, St. Catharines, Ontario L2S 3W5, Canada (Ontario, St. Catharines)
+1 (289) 362-4433
12:00 PM - 10:30 PM (Today)
Mon - Wed: 12:00 PM - 10:30 PM
Thu - Fri: 12:00 PM - 11:30 PM
Sat: 12:00 PM - 10:30 PM
Sun: 12:00 PM - 09:30 PM

Pie Guy’s Pizzeria in St. Catharines is a delightful culinary haven for pizza enthusiasts. Known for its mouth-watering pizzas crafted from fresh, high-quality ingredients, the pizzeria offers a wide array of topping choices, catering to both traditional and adventurous palates. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it’s the perfect spot for family dinners or a casual meal with friends. Whether dining in or taking out, Pie Guy’s Pizzeria promises a satisfying and delicious experience every time.

Check out TOP-10 Best Italian restaurants in St. Catharines, Ontario
Overview
Menu

Menu

Disclaimer: Menu prices and items are subject to change and may differ from what is listed, as restaurants update their menus frequently. The menu provided is for reference only. For the most accurate and up-to-date information, please contact the restaurant directly.
Design Your Own Pie
Specialty Pies
Jumbo Wings
Appetizers
Fresh Cut Fries, Poutine & Fingers
Subs & Sandwiches
Salads
Beverages

Design Your Own Pie

Design Your Own Pie (12 Slice)

$17.99
4, 8, 12 or 24 slice with traditional homemade tomato sauce or white base and mozzarella cheese. Each topping for an additional charge for 4 slice / 8 slice / 12 slice / 24 slice. Gluten free 8 slice crust or keto friendly 8 slice crust for an additional charge.

Design Your Own Pie (8 Slice)

$14.99
4, 8, 12 or 24 slice with traditional homemade tomato sauce or white base and mozzarella cheese. Each topping for an additional charge for 4 slice / 8 slice / 12 slice / 24 slice. Gluten free 8 slice crust or keto friendly 8 slice crust for an additional charge.

Design Your Own Pie (4 Slice)

$9.5
4, 8, 12 or 24 slice with traditional homemade tomato sauce or white base and mozzarella cheese. Each topping for an additional charge for 4 slice / 8 slice / 12 slice / 24 slice. Gluten free 8 slice crust or keto friendly 8 slice crust for an additional charge.

Specialty Pies

Greek Pizza (New) (12 Slice)

$32.99
Our house white base and mozzarella topped with chicken breast, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, feta cheese, crushed garlic and kalamata olives. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

The Italian Stallion (8 Slice)

$22.99
Spicy. A spicy favourite with pie guys homemade tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, spicy pepperoni, hot italian sausage, hot capicola and hot peppers. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust for an additional charge.

Steak Pizza Pie (12 Slice)

$35.99
Grilled rib eye steak with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers. Topped with mozzarella cheese and special pie guys bbq sauce. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

The New Yorker XXL

$34.99
Pie guys homemade tomato sauce, parmesan, asiago & mozzarella cheeses, pepperoni, a little more pepperoni and don't forget some more pepperoni.

Mediterranean Pizza Pie (12 Slice)

$28.99
Vegetarian. Roasted red peppers, tomatoes, onions and feta cheese. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust for an additional charge.

Extreme Cheese (New) (8 Slice)

$23.99
Pie guys tomato sauce, parmesan, asiago, cheddar, monterey jack and mozzarella cheeses. Gluten free 8 slice or keto 8 slice crust for an additional charge.

BBQ Chicken Pizza Pie (8 Slice)

$28.99
Grilled chicken breast with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers, mozzarella cheese and special pie guys bbq sauce. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

BBQ Chicken Pizza Pie (12 Slice)

$35.99
Grilled chicken breast with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers, mozzarella cheese and special pie guys bbq sauce. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Mexican Pizza Pie (New) (12 Slice)

$30.99
Spicy. Seasoned ground beef, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, jalapeño peppers, tomato slices and onions. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Pizza Pie with "The Works" (4 Slice)

$16.99
Pie guys homemade tomato sauce with a blend of mozzarella cheese topped with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, onions, green olives, hot peppers and bacon. 4 slice, 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Pizza Pie with "The Works" (8 Slice)

$26.99
Pie guys homemade tomato sauce with a blend of mozzarella cheese topped with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, onions, green olives, hot peppers and bacon. 4 slice, 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Pizza Pie with "The Works" (12 Slice)

$34.99
Pie guys homemade tomato sauce with a blend of mozzarella cheese topped with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, onions, green olives, hot peppers and bacon. 4 slice, 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Greek Pizza (New) (8 Slice)

$25.99
Our house white base and mozzarella topped with chicken breast, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, feta cheese, crushed garlic and kalamata olives. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Steak Pizza Pie (8 Slice)

$28.99
Grilled rib eye steak with sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers. Topped with mozzarella cheese and special pie guys bbq sauce. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

The Italian Stallion (12 Slice)

$28.99
Spicy. A spicy favourite with pie guys homemade tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, spicy pepperoni, hot italian sausage, hot capicola and hot peppers. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust for an additional charge.

Mediterranean Pizza Pie (8 Slice)

$23.99
Vegetarian. Roasted red peppers, tomatoes, onions and feta cheese. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust for an additional charge.

Extreme Cheese (New) (12 Slice)

$28.99
Pie guys tomato sauce, parmesan, asiago, cheddar, monterey jack and mozzarella cheeses. Gluten free 8 slice or keto 8 slice crust for an additional charge.

"The Fun-Guy"

$27.99
Mushroom medley, mozzarella, fresh herbs on a classic crust. Options include 8 or 12 slices.

The Godfather (New) (8 Slice)

$23.99
Spicy. Tomato sauce, asiago & mozzarella cheeses, hot capicola, hot calabrese salami & hot italian sausage.

The Godfather (New) (12 Slice)

$28.99
Spicy. Tomato sauce, asiago & mozzarella cheeses, hot capicola, hot calabrese salami & hot italian sausage.

"Dill-Icious"

$26.99
Dill-icious pie topped with creamy dill sauce; choose from 8 or 12 slices.

Mexican Pizza Pie (New) (8 Slice)

$24.99
Spicy. Seasoned ground beef, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, jalapeño peppers, tomato slices and onions. 8 slice and 12 slice. Gluten free 8 slice pizza crust or keto crust 8 slice for an additional charge.

Jumbo Wings

Jumbo Wings (4 Lb)

$55.96
Gluten free. Bbq wings: mild, medium, hot and suicide! / buffalo wings: medium, hot and extra hot / honey garlic / cajun / sweet chili. Served with celery, carrots and blue cheese.

Jumbo Wings (2 Lb)

$27.98
Gluten free. Bbq wings: mild, medium, hot and suicide! / buffalo wings: medium, hot and extra hot / honey garlic / cajun / sweet chili. Served with celery, carrots and blue cheese.

Jumbo Wings (3 Lb)

$41.97
Gluten free. Bbq wings: mild, medium, hot and suicide! / buffalo wings: medium, hot and extra hot / honey garlic / cajun / sweet chili. Served with celery, carrots and blue cheese.

Jumbo Wings (1 Lb)

$13.99
Gluten free. Bbq wings: mild, medium, hot and suicide! / buffalo wings: medium, hot and extra hot / honey garlic / cajun / sweet chili. Served with celery, carrots and blue cheese.

Jumbo Wings (5 Lb)

$69.95
Gluten free. Bbq wings: mild, medium, hot and suicide! / buffalo wings: medium, hot and extra hot / honey garlic / cajun / sweet chili. Served with celery, carrots and blue cheese.

Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks

$13.99
With homemade marinara sauce for dipping.

Dill Pickle Spears

$13.99
Lightly battered and deep fried sliced pickle coins. Great for dipping in our aioli sauce.

Deep Fried Wontons

$12.99
With sweet chili thai sauce.

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$11.99
Add bacon for additional charge.

Onion Rings

$12.99
Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.

Cheese Balls

$13.99
Melt in your mouth cheddar cheese balls deep fried with sour cream on the side.

Potato Skins

$14.99
Potato skins, baked until crisp, typically include cheddar cheese, bacon, and a dollop of sour cream, often garnished with green onions.

Jalapeño Poppers

$13.99
Spicy.

Fresh Cut Fries, Poutine & Fingers

Fries

$8.99
Add gravy for additional charge.

Chicken Fingers

$17.99
Served with fries, cut fresh daily and plum sauce.

Poutine

$13.99
Add extra cheese for additional charge.

Subs & Sandwiches

Chicken Club Sub

$16.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a toasted foot long bun.

Warm & Toasted Italian Subs

$15.99
Our foot long italian subs are topped with pie guys homemade sauce, parmesan and mozzarella. Meatball or chicken parmesan.

Pie Guys "Regular Guy" Sub

$11.99
Our foot long subs are topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato and our delicious sub sauce.

Grilled Subs

$16.99
Our toasted foot long grilled subs featuring sautéed mushrooms, onions and green peppers with melted provolone or mozzarella cheese. Topped with lettuce and tomato.

Pie Guys Chicken Sandwich

$10.99
Crispy chicken breast, lettuce, tomato on a toasted brioche bun with regular or spicy aioli.

Salads

Greek Salad

$14.99
Lettuce, red onions, grape tomatoes, feta cheese, kalamata olives with a homemade vinaigrette dressing.

Caesar Salad

$14.99
Enough for two ! Romaine lettuce, real bacon, parmesan cheese, croutons with a caesar dressing.

House Salad

$13.99
Baby greens, red onions, grape tomatoes, and green peppers, topped with our own balsamic dressing.

Cranberry Pecan Salad

$15.99
Baby greens, feta cheese, dried cranberries, candied pecans with a homemade sweet onion vinaigrette dressing.

Beverages

7 Up

$2
Can.

Pepsi

$2
Can.

Iced Tea

$2
Can.

Ginger Ale

$2
Can.

Dad's Root Beer

$4
A classic, carbonated root beer offering a blend of traditional flavors, often including vanilla, licorice, and sassafras.

Diet Pepsi

$2
Can.

Bottled Water

$2
Pure and refreshing bottled water.

Reviews for Pie Guy’s Pizzeria in St. Catharines, Ontario

3
Yelp
3

You might be interested

Crave Pizza in St. Catharines

Crave Pizza

American, Italian
Ontario, St. Catharines
Open Now Closed
Crave Pizza is a culinary gem in St. Catharines, Ontario, offering a delightful fusion of classic and contemporary flavors. Known for its handcrafted, stone-baked pizzas, the restaurant emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and innovative toppings. Guests can enjoy a warm, inviting atmosphere, whether dining in or taking out. Perfect for family outings or casual get-togethers, Crave Pizza is dedicated to serving up slices of happiness with every order.
View Menu
Edible Arrangements in St. Catharines

Edible Arrangements

Flowers, Gift Store
Ontario, St. Catharines
Open Now Closed
Edible Arrangements in St. Catharines offers a delightful selection of fresh fruit bouquets and gourmet treats, perfect for any occasion. With an emphasis on creativity and quality, each arrangement is crafted to impress, making birthdays, anniversaries, and celebrations extra special. Beyond fruit, they offer chocolate-covered strawberries, smoothies, and fruit salads. Count on their friendly staff to help choose the perfect gift that is both delicious and memorable.
View Menu
Korean BBQ Town in St. Catharines

Korean BBQ Town

Asian, BBQ
Ontario, St. Catharines
Open Now Closed
Korean BBQ Town offers an authentic and dynamic dining experience in the heart of St. Catharines. Known for its interactive approach, guests can grill a variety of marinated meats and fresh vegetables right at their table. The restaurant's menu boasts traditional Korean flavors, from spicy kimchi to savory bulgogi, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. With its warm ambiance and friendly service, Korean BBQ Town is the perfect spot for both casual meals and special occasions, sure to satisfy and delight.
View Menu
The Curry Pot in St. Catharines

The Curry Pot

Asian, Group Friendly
Ontario, St. Catharines
Open Now Closed
The Curry Pot is a delightful culinary destination in St. Catharines, offering a rich tapestry of authentic Indian flavors. Known for its vibrant and aromatic dishes, this charming eatery caters to both traditional tastes and modern preferences. Guests can enjoy a diverse menu featuring classic curries, freshly baked naan, and an array of vegetarian options. With its warm ambiance and friendly service, The Curry Pot provides a memorable dining experience for spice enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
View Menu

    Claim Listing

    Hint or Error Message

    Hint or Error Message

    Hint or Error Message

    Hint or Error Message

    Hint or Error Message

    Hint or Error Message


    Thanks for the submission!
    We will contact you shortly

      Report a problem

      This is to report a problem on MainMenus.com, these messages DO NOT go to the restaurants.

      Hint or Error Message

      Hint or Error Message

      Thanks for the submission!
      We will contact you shortly