Home / Ontario / St. Catharines

Discover TOP-10 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines in 2026

Bro’s Pizza & Wings

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Bro's Pizza & Wings in St. Catharines is a go-to spot for delicious comfort food. Known for its mouth-watering pizzas topped with fresh ingredients and perfectly seasoned wings, this local favorite offers a cozy atmosphere for dining in or taking out. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or adventurous specialty wings, Bro's Pizza & Wings delivers satisfying flavors and friendly service that keeps customers coming back for more. Perfect for family dinners or casual get-togethers with friends!

View Menu

Twice the Deal Pizza

American, Italian

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Twice the Deal Pizza in St. Catharines offers a delightful pizza experience with a focus on quality and value. Known for their generous portions and tasty toppings, this pizzeria caters to diverse tastes. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni, a veggie delight, or a specialty pie, they have something for everyone. Their menu also features a range of sides, perfect for pairing with your pizza. Enjoy fresh, hot, and satisfying meals that won't break the bank at Twice the Deal Pizza.

View Menu

Pizza Pizza

Chicken, Desserts

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Pizza Pizza in St. Catharines is a go-to spot for delicious and affordable pizza. Known for its extensive menu, it offers a variety of toppings and crust options that cater to every taste. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni or a gourmet creation, this friendly establishment ensures fast and reliable service. Ideal for families, students, or anyone craving a quick pizza fix, Pizza Pizza delivers quality and satisfaction with each slice.

View Menu

Two For One Pizza and Wings

Fast Food, Italian

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Two For One Pizza and Wings is a go-to destination in St Catharines, Ontario, for pizza and chicken wing aficionados. Known for its generous deals and mouthwatering selections, this pizzeria prides itself on delivering quality, flavor-packed meals that cater to all tastes. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, their diverse menu and friendly service are sure to leave you satisfied.

Papa John’s

American, Group Friendly

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Papa John's in St. Catharines offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for indulging in handcrafted pizzas made with quality ingredients. Known for its delicious signature pizzas and attentive service, this location promises a delightful dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a special treat, Papa John's provides a menu full of tasty options, including customizable pizzas and delectable sides to satisfy every craving.

View Menu

Antipastos

Italian, Pizza

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Antipastos is a beloved gem nestled in St Catharines, Ontario, known for its delightful array of culinary treasures. This Italian deli and eatery tempts locals and visitors alike with its curated selection of cheeses, meats, and house-made specialties. A family-owned haven for gourmet enthusiasts, Antipastos prides itself on offering an authentic taste of Italy, complete with warm, inviting service that makes every visit memorable.

Crust N Cream

Italian, Pizza

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Crust N Cream is a delightful spot in St. Catharines, Ontario, known for its artisan pizzas and decadent ice creams. This charming eatery combines the best of savory and sweet, offering a menu that caters to all cravings. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita or a unique flavor twist, their hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas are sure to impress. Finish off your meal with a scoop of their creamy, homemade ice cream for a truly satisfying experience.

Visit Website View Menu

IL FORNELLO

Italian, Plant Based

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

IL FORNELLO in St. Catharines offers a delightful dining experience characterized by its authentic Italian cuisine and inviting atmosphere. Known for its wood-fired pizzas and a diverse selection of pasta dishes, the restaurant balances traditional flavors with modern culinary flair. Guests can enjoy a warm, contemporary setting perfect for family gatherings or intimate dinners. With a focus on quality ingredients and exceptional service, IL FORNELLO promises a memorable culinary journey for every visitor.

Visit Website View Menu

Fabio’s Pizza

Italian, Panini

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Fabio's Pizza is a beloved local gem in St. Catharines, Ontario, known for its delicious, handcrafted pizzas that combine traditional recipes with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make it a perfect spot for family gatherings, casual dates, or takeaway delights. With a diverse menu featuring classic favorites and inventive specialties, Fabio's ensures a satisfying dining experience that keeps pizza lovers coming back for more.

View Menu

Super 2 For 1 Pizza

Italian, Takeout

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Super 2 For 1 Pizza in St. Catharines offers a delicious variety of pizzas with an unbeatable value. Known for its generous portions and diverse toppings, this local favorite provides something for every pizza lover. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni or a gourmet creation, every slice promises freshness and flavor. Quick, friendly service ensures your meal is satisfying from order to bite. Perfect for a family meal or a casual get-together, Super 2 For 1 Pizza delivers quality and value every time.

Visit Website View Menu

See all Italian restaurants in St. Catharines

Can't find the business?

Click the button to learn more about how to be featured on this list.

Learn More

You might be interested

Crave Pizza

American, Italian

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Crave Pizza is a culinary gem in St. Catharines, Ontario, offering a delightful fusion of classic and contemporary flavors. Known for its handcrafted, stone-baked pizzas, the restaurant emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and innovative toppings. Guests can enjoy a warm, inviting atmosphere, whether dining in or taking out. Perfect for family outings or casual get-togethers, Crave Pizza is dedicated to serving up slices of happiness with every order.

View Menu

Edible Arrangements

Flowers, Gift Store

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Edible Arrangements in St. Catharines offers a delightful selection of fresh fruit bouquets and gourmet treats, perfect for any occasion. With an emphasis on creativity and quality, each arrangement is crafted to impress, making birthdays, anniversaries, and celebrations extra special. Beyond fruit, they offer chocolate-covered strawberries, smoothies, and fruit salads. Count on their friendly staff to help choose the perfect gift that is both delicious and memorable.

View Menu

Korean BBQ Town

Asian, BBQ

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

Korean BBQ Town offers an authentic and dynamic dining experience in the heart of St. Catharines. Known for its interactive approach, guests can grill a variety of marinated meats and fresh vegetables right at their table. The restaurant's menu boasts traditional Korean flavors, from spicy kimchi to savory bulgogi, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. With its warm ambiance and friendly service, Korean BBQ Town is the perfect spot for both casual meals and special occasions, sure to satisfy and delight.

View Menu

The Curry Pot

Asian, Group Friendly

Ontario, St. Catharines

Open Now Closed

The Curry Pot is a delightful culinary destination in St. Catharines, offering a rich tapestry of authentic Indian flavors. Known for its vibrant and aromatic dishes, this charming eatery caters to both traditional tastes and modern preferences. Guests can enjoy a diverse menu featuring classic curries, freshly baked naan, and an array of vegetarian options. With its warm ambiance and friendly service, The Curry Pot provides a memorable dining experience for spice enthusiasts and newcomers alike.

View Menu

Discover TOP-10 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines in 2026

Can't find the business?

You might be interested

Filters