Scarlet Exclusive - Old Montréal, Quebec

Atmosphere was nice. Salad was too salty. Beef tartare was ok. Fiancées swordfish was the size of an average person’s index and I had to return my cod dish because it wasn’t properly cooked twice and had a very strong fish smell! At least staff was comprehensive but we won’t ... be going back! Read more

If I'd done a review a year and a half ago we would be giving a 4 or 5. My husband and I have enjoyed this place on special occasions ever since our first visit in Dec 2016. At this point in time though 3 stars is what we're giving, as ... we made a reservation here for our 1st wedding anniversary on June 16 2018 and did so online on May 2nd. We then received a message on June 11 that a "technical error" lost our booking and only asked for me to confirm receipt of message, so I responded back asking if there was any way to recover the booking as our reservation was made over a month ago and this came less than a week before the date of the reservation. Response received: no, because a wedding was booked 9 months ago for the date in question. We're rather disappointed in this outcome as we have enjoyed ourselves here before, and also really unimpressed that even though apparently a wedding reception was booked 9 months ago, as of a month ago the same date was shown on their site's reservation schedule as having availability. Read more

The venue is really nice and sensual, however the service was quite slow. In the beginning, while I was waiting for my guests the waitress would come very often, as soon as they arrived, she disappeared. The tagliolinies where too salty, but good. So people who ordered the salty dishes, ... got dessert in compensation.The chicken was tasteless, but the duck breast was good. The drinks are really good and worth the 15$, but of course on the pricey side compared to Santos and Flyjin. The music is not great either. The churros ay dios what a disappointment , not sweet and tasty at all and not enough dulce de leche. Also for the valet service which is advertised as 20$, the guy charged my sister 25$, I think he included his tip. I find that very discriminative and agressive. This would never happen if she was an old white male. Read more

2 people without reservations. Got in pretty quick on a friday night. Drinks are a tad bit expensive but the great food is a bit less so it evens out. Good vibes excellent staff. Would go there again. Had the cold meat and cheese platter which was very tasty.

I had heard that this was a fancy place to go and so I got all dressed up to try it out with colleagues. The setting is fancy but the food is not at the same level. Dishes could have been more inventive, and the sommelier could have ... been more helpful with the wine list. Service was also very slow with food taking forever to come out of the kitchen. Read more