Home / Ontario / Newmarket

Discover TOP-10 Best Italian Restaurants in Newmarket in 2025

Pi Co. Pizza

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Pi Co. Pizza in Newmarket offers a fresh and innovative approach to pizza, blending tradition with a contemporary twist. Renowned for its customizable, handcrafted pies, Pi Co. invites guests to curate their own culinary creations using premium ingredients and a variety of toppings. The vibrant and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for both casual lunches and relaxed dinners. Whether dining in or grabbing a quick bite, Pi Co. promises a delicious and memorable experience.

View Menu

Pizzaiolo

American, Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Pizzaiolo in Newmarket offers a delightful taste of authentic Italian pizza with a modern twist. Known for its fresh, high-quality ingredients and a wide variety of toppings, it caters to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make it a perfect spot for family dinners or casual gatherings. Vegetarian and gluten-free options ensure that all pizza lovers find something to enjoy.

View Menu

Pizza Nova

Italian, Pizza

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Pizza Nova in Newmarket offers a delightful pizza experience characterized by fresh, high-quality ingredients and authentic Italian flavors. Known for their diverse menu, they serve a variety of specialty pizzas, oven-baked pastas, and tasty sides, catering to both traditional and adventurous palates. With a welcoming ambiance and friendly service, Pizza Nova is a great spot for family dining or a quick, satisfying meal. Enjoy the rich and savory flavors that make every bite memorable.

View Menu

East Side Mario’s

Italian, Pizza

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

East Side Mario's in Newmarket offers a vibrant Italian-American dining experience, perfect for families and friends. Known for its lively atmosphere and generous portions, the restaurant features classic favorites like pasta, pizza, and their famous unlimited soup or salad and garlic homeloaf. With its cheerful décor and welcoming staff, East Side Mario's delivers a taste of Little Italy in a comfortable, relaxed setting, ensuring a memorable meal for all ages. Buon appetito!

View Menu

Boston Pizza

Italian, Steak

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Boston Pizza in Newmarket offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families, friends, and sports enthusiasts. This local favorite is renowned for its diverse menu, which features a mouthwatering selection of classic and gourmet pizzas, flavorful pasta dishes, hearty burgers, and fresh salads. With multiple TVs throughout the restaurant, it's an ideal spot to catch the game while enjoying a cold beverage. The friendly staff and inviting ambiance make every visit memorable.

View Menu

Score Pizza

American, Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Score Pizza offers a delightful culinary experience in Newmarket, boasting a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual dining. Specializing in handcrafted, stone-baked pizzas, each creation is customizable with a wide array of fresh toppings and sauces, ensuring a meal to satisfy every palate. Complement your pizza with a selection of refreshing beverages, and enjoy the friendly service that makes Score Pizza a local favorite for both lunch and dinner.

Visit Website View Menu

Mercato on Main

Comfort Food, Group Friendly

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Mercato on Main offers a delightful culinary experience in the heart of Newmarket. This charming eatery combines the warmth of a traditional Italian market with the vibrant energy of a modern café. Guests are invited to savor a diverse menu featuring authentic Italian delicacies, gourmet sandwiches, and freshly brewed coffee. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and commitment to quality, Mercato on Main is a beloved spot for both casual lunches and special gatherings.

View Menu

Topper’s Pizza

Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Topper's Pizza in Newmarket offers a delightful pizza experience, known for its fresh ingredients and mouthwatering flavors. Dive into a menu that features a variety of classic and innovative pizzas, complemented by a selection of sides and desserts. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make it a popular spot for families and friends to gather. Whether dining in, taking out, or opting for delivery, Topper's Pizza promises quality and satisfaction in every bite.

View Menu

Ristorante Orsini

Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Ristorante Orsini offers an authentic Italian dining experience in the heart of Newmarket. With a warm, inviting atmosphere, the restaurant is known for its exquisite selection of traditional Italian dishes, crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From perfectly cooked pastas to mouthwatering pizzas, each dish is a celebration of Italy's culinary heritage. The attentive staff and cozy ambiance make it an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and family gatherings.

Visit Website View Menu

Rubino’s Pizzeria & Bistro

American, Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Rubino's Pizzeria & Bistro offers a delightful fusion of traditional Italian flavors and modern culinary flair, nestled in the heart of Newmarket. Known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and exceptional service, this charming eatery serves up handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and a variety of bistro-style dishes made with the freshest ingredients. Perfect for family gatherings or intimate dinners, Rubino's promises a memorable dining experience that captures the authentic taste of Italy.

View Menu

See all Italian restaurants in Newmarket

Can't find the business?

Click the button to learn more about how to be featured on this list.

Learn More

You might be interested

Pizzaiolo

American, Italian

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

View Menu

Samosa Master

Indian, Street Food

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Samosa Master in Newmarket offers a delightful culinary experience centered around authentic South Asian flavors. Renowned for their perfectly crisp and savory samosas, this eatery provides a variety of fillings to satisfy diverse palates. Whether you're craving a traditional snack or exploring bold spices, Samosa Master uses fresh ingredients to ensure a taste that transports you to the heart of India. Excellent for quick bites and sharing with friends, it's a beloved local gem for food enthusiasts.

View Menu

Zucca’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

Italian, Pasta

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Zucca's Ristorante & Pizzeria offers a delightful culinary experience where authentic Italian flavors come to life. The cozy, inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for family gatherings or an intimate dinner. Specializing in traditional pizzas, hearty pastas, and savory antipasti, each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and a passion for excellence. With friendly service and a commitment to quality, Zucca's promises a memorable dining experience for all Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

View Menu

Ippon Ramen

Asian, Ramen

Ontario, Newmarket

Open Now Closed

Ippon Ramen offers a delightful culinary escape into the heart of Japanese cuisine right in Newmarket. Renowned for its rich and flavorful broths, freshly made noodles, and authentic toppings, each bowl of ramen is crafted with precision and passion. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for casual dining or a quick meal. Whether you're a ramen aficionado or a newcomer, Ippon Ramen promises an exceptional dining experience that captures the essence of traditional Japanese artistry.

View Menu

Discover TOP-10 Best Italian Restaurants in Newmarket in 2025

Can't find the business?

You might be interested

Filters