Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza - Milton, Ontario

I would suggest not showing up in the first hour of opening… better to let them get into the swing. I’d say it’s a great date location… the pizza is great - the aperitif of meatballs was a bit cool - but still tasty. The drinks brought our cost up… ... but worth it. Read more

Going to start by saying, this place has great ingredients and the food does taste decent. I do enjoy the pizza if you’re looking for this kind of wood fire style. But from a value perspective I just can’t go back here. Takeout for one pasta, one pizza and one ... calamari came to $80. See the calamari (5piece) portion size below and see for yourself. Place has great service just really disappointed on what you get for the money. Read more

Generous portions of well prepared food. One Caesar salad order was enough for three people. The music was a little loud for normal conversation.

First time at a Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza, and probably my last. Food was super overpriced, the price does not reflect on the quality of the food. If I'm paying $30 plus on a pizza I expect a good pizza. Service was good, our waitress was super nice and accommodative. ... The food took forever to arrive, and once it did, it was a disappointment. Read more

The food was delicious especially the calamari. They definitely make great pizzas and serving sizes are great. I would have enjoyed my time a bit more here if they turned down the AC a little bit as it was really cold inside. The interior definitely created a homey feeling and I ... loved it. Would come back and try different items for sure next time. Read more