Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta - Barrie, Ontario

Beyond incredible place!!! Looove their pastas and pizza, I always recommend it! Saw the manager literally give a customer his glasses to let them read the menu, that’s service!!! thank you guyssss

To be honest..I went there because as the name indicate..I thought of trying their pizza ..but it's kind of a pub that provides you drinks and snacks.. the staff is friendly but overall the atmosphere is very numb. Won't be going there again..tried their nachos and qusidela and to ... be honest , I liked their nachos.. everything else was just okay.. a wide variety of options for non vegetarians to choose from. Read more

I don't know how this place has a rating over 2. The in-house slices are absolutely wretched. They actually take a spray bottle of water and squirt it all over the slice before they reheat it, to moisten it I guess? They squirt down your slice right in ... front of you, like it is a completely normal practice. How many "gourmet" restaurants squirt water all over the food in front of you? If the slice is dry, don't be cheap, just put a sprinkle of fresh cheese on top. If it is too dry... throw it out. I was charged $8 for what you see in that picture. My goodness. If the owner comments on this saying that they don't spray the slices down, I will tell you that I've witnessed him do it himself. To make things worse, Circle K started serving Pizza slices. They weren't great, but they were better than Sicilian and at an affordable price. Sicilian complained to the property management company about the competition and Circle K was forced to pull their pizza at that location. Seriously, how bad is your pizza that you can't compete with gas station pizza. Now not only is he making a bad product at his own restaurant but is forcing other places to stop serving products. Just get better, try harder, don't cry foul because people are voting with their wallet. Sicilian has like 25 different "Poutines" on the menu, none of them have cheese curd. If you are going to use shredded cheese, call it "cheese fries" or something. Staff is nice though. Read more

This is a nice, cozy, casual pizza & pasta restaurant. Lots of menu items, and all at reasonable prices. Service is very friendly. The pizza and pasta are very good, but I would prefer that the pizza sauce and pasta sauce had more flavour. (As a comparison reference, I would say ... that Pizza Nova has one of the tastiest pizza sauces.) Overall: I will return soon to enjoy more great food, and I highly recommend that you try this restaurant as well. Read more

Pizza was amazing 😍 Staff very friendly and their menu is huge. So many authentic Italian/ Sicilian dishes I got the Amaricano pizza this time but I definitely plan on going back with my family and trying more things♥️ best Italian food I’ve had in Barrie 🙌 and I’m Italian 😘🤌 also ... their fries were PERFECT 🔥🔥🔥 Read more