McReilly’s Pub & Restaurant - Barrie, Ontario

Underrated gem in downtown Barrie. I've never been disappointed once with the food here. The staff are amazing and friendly. You feel like family walking in. I can't help but come back for the beef dip. Highly recommend stopping in for lunch or dinner.

Hands down some of the BEST food in Barrie!! Everything tastes home made. * The smash burger 10/10 and I've had my fair share of them. * The french beef dip 10/10, seriously the best I've ever had. * Mozzarella sticks 10/10 home made and comes with a killer marinara dipping ... sauce. AND, You must try the *Sticky Toffee Pudding*, it's a show stopper Read more

Exceptional meal, service and atmosphere for my birthday dinner with family. The roasted beet salad was a treasure trove of surprisingly complimentary contrasts from the candied nuts to the pickled red onions and cheese in the house balsamic dressing that harmonized textures and flavours in perfect balance. Vegetarian options pleased ... my wife. The cost of the meal was very reasonable and I think the same meal would cost 2 or 3 times more in Toronto. We’ll be back soon! Read more

I came in today for the French onion soup and the Buffalo chicken wrap. Absolutely amazing and delicious! I also had it with the house dill sauce and it was so good!! Will definitely be back!

I had their best selling roast beef sandwich dinner here. It was nice and juicy. The sandwich comes with french fries. The fries is a bit too salty for me. The waiter was friendly and helpful. I went in the summer so can sit outside in the patio and enjoy the ... vibe of Barrie's downtown. The price is reasonable for a nice restaurant in downtown area. I spent $30 for the sandwich and a glass of ginger ale after tax. Read more